Poll Dancing

Will the industry redeem itself for the mid-terms?

Illustration by Peter Noonan

The outcome of the 2016 presidential election was shocking to nearly every American. Reportedly, even Donald Trump himself didn’t expect to win the contest. But then he began winning state after state that he was supposed to lose.

There wasn’t much that Republicans and Democrats agreed on during that election, but they did agree on the collective wisdom of the polls, and those polls said that it was a sure bet that Hillary Clinton would defeat Trump.

And as we head into the homestretch of the 2018 midterm election, there are two points all voters should keep in mind: Polls will still drive the converstation, and there is no reason to believe that these polls are any better than the ones from two years ago.

You’d think that the 2016 election would serve as a crisis moment for the polling industry, but instead of considering what went wrong and how to improve methods, literally nothing has changed in the way polls are being conducted.

While there has been a noted skepticism over polling in the press and less coverage of polls, bad polls are still being put out, still being reported on, and still frame how everyday people, candidates and political donors see their races.

Specifically regarding New Hampshire, in the two years since the 2016 contest, there have been two developments on local polling, but neither has been a fundamental shift. The first is that, after years of criticism, WMUR-TV ended its official relationship with the University of New Hampshire Survey Center. This came after the last WMUR/UNH Granite State Poll before the 2016 election showed Clinton winning the state by 15 percentage points. She did win the state, but only by three-tenths of a percent.

Meanwhile, the Saint Anselm College Institute of Politics has now begun polling in a regular, but infrequent way. Their poll, it should be noted, is outsourced and conducted by a third party. It’s a new, untested poll, so it’s still unclear if their numbers should be seen as credible either.

For at least a decade, the best polls of New Hampshire are conducted by firms from outside of the state. There is no secret sauce involved, but organizations such as Suffolk University, CNN and NBC actually spend serious money to do serious polls here.

This isn’t a presidential year with the state’s contested Electoral College votes up for grabs, so there is likely to be very little polling of the Granite State. However, what polling does come out will drive press coverage, decide who will get to participate in debates, and impact how candidates campaign. All this in spite of the fact that there is little reason for these polls to have that kind of impact.

Where does that leave the voter?

It means that voters shouldn’t vote based on who is expected to win, but should pick who they think will do the best job. Because, really, who knows who is actually winning until the votes are counted?

More politics features you might be interested in

The Power of Power

Healthcare, Trump and the economy are all lower on NH’s wish list.

Open the Gates

After the midterms, a flood of presidential candidates will take aim at New Hampshire.

Picture This

Your 2018 ballot might be one worth remembering.

Beaming it in?

Some candidates have tenuous local connections.
Edit ModuleEdit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Popular Articles

  1. The Power of Power
    Healthcare, Trump and the economy are all lower on NH’s wish list.
  2. 2018's Best New Restaurants
    Over the last year, Food Editor Susan Laughlin traveled the state, searching for notable new...
  3. 2018 It List
    If you wanted to host the ultimate cocktail party, these are the people you’d want to invite....
  4. Cider Donuts (Where To Find Them and How To Make Them)
    Enjoy a cider donut recipe plus local NH stores and orchards where you can get hot and fresh...
  5. Prepared for Anything
    As the global future grows more unpredictable, some people are staking out their own worlds and...
  6. 16 New Granite State Breweries
    Get ready to experience the thrill of discovery. From the top of the state to the coast, here are...
  7. How Food Can Affect Your Mood
    What you do (and don’t) eat can affect your stress level and more.
  8. Brewing Beer is a Labor of Love
    The co-founder of Lithermans Limited made his passion a full-time job.
Edit ModuleShow Tags