The weather outside is frightful, but my dear, the night is delightful. A snowy eve enrobed in the warmth of a cozy inn is one of life’s greatest joys. Better yet, after lingering over a four-course dinner, your room is just steps away. This is the stage. How does it get set? Who attempts to create these engaging scenarios?
There seems to be a “hospitality virus” that lies dormant in some people until mid-life. At a point, their chosen careers seem tiresome, and they start perusing Internet sites designed for innkeepers. How exactly this “virus” works and manifests itself is another story, but for now, I will tell you the story of new innkeeper Steve Allen and the Sugar Hill Inn.
Allen, in his mid-50s, had owned and operated a shipping and packing business in New Jersey. He enjoyed success and he built a good nest egg, but it was time to do something else. Really, how many boxes can one fill with Styrofoam peanuts and still feel fulfilled?
Following his muse, he completed a chef-level class at the French Culinary Institute in New York City. His next challenge was to find an outlet for his newly-honed cooking skills. Usually, new chefs have to start at the bottom of someone else’s restaurant. Allen, wanting to skip the yeoman’s duty portion of the career change, decided to open his own place. But where? A bed and breakfast operation with a good-sized dining room seemed ideal. A few other prerequisites, like decent quarters for himself, brought him to the Sugar Hill Inn in May of 2006. The property was built in 1789 as a farmhouse and has 14 guest rooms, including several separate cottages and a perfect-sized dining room.
Sugar Hill, not far from I-93, is a quiet village that comes to life in June with the blooming of the lupines. The town was a favorite of Bette Davis, who stayed at the inn while her summer home was being built. Harmon’s, a perfect country store with its own famous, aged cheddar cheese, is down the street along with the Sampler, the Sunset Hill House, Polly’s Pancakes and the Hilltop Inn. There is not much more besides the incredible views, a picturesque chapel and the serene peace. Perfect for a quiet getaway that is nonetheless 10 minutes from skiing at Loon or shopping in Littleton.
Running a B&B appears to be a two-person job. You find married couples and life companions sharing the job responsibilities. Allen, single, corresponded with Theresa Spear of Connecticut, who was also single and longed to become an innkeeper. They eventually met at an innkeeper’s conference and decided to become business partners. The soft-spoken Spear handles details behind the scenes, while Allen, is out front and center, playing the consummate host.
At 4:30 p.m. Allen, in his chef’s jacket, holds court in the bar. Guests wander in from their afternoon excursions and gather for a cup of tea. But Allen goes a little further this afternoon and holds a chocolate-tasting lesson on what makes good chocolate. We learn, among other things, that a piece of quality chocolate should break cleanly. After the tasting, Allen serves a variety of hors d'oeuvres. He is clearly enjoying this outpouring of hospitality as guests chat and mingle in his newly-refurbished bar.
Finally, it is time for dinner. Allen was the sole chef for the first few months, but quickly realized he needed to spend more time out of the kitchen. He hired Chef Val Fortin, previously of The Mount Washington Resort, to concentrate on delivering beautiful dishes for dinner, while using his own cooking skills for breakfast and occasional desserts.
The dining room is a bit eclectic looking, with new designer wallpaper, but chairs leftover from its past incarnation, give the impression that renovation is still in progress. Windows on three sides let in bright sunshine for breakfast and give you a taste of the views you find farther up the hill.
Dinner at the inn is prix fixe at $45 for four courses, a very good value. The menu offers a choice of four appetizers, two salads, five entrées and several desserts. Everything is made to order from scratch. Importantly, serving sizes are appropriate and you don’t waddle away from the table wishing you had worn a Spandex jumpsuit. The wine list is respectable with several good-value wines.
First to appear is an amusé bouche. This chef’s treat to tantalize the palate is a good measure of what’s to come. We find this “treat” an artfully arranged small portion of house-cured salmon that sparks our interest in the forthcoming meal.
Appetizer choices included a sampling of the chef’s favorite soups; a trio of small cups just large enough to enjoy the taste of the squash-apple, French onion and clam chowder, with one extra spoonful to share with my husband. The homemade mushroom ravioli with sage butter and truffle oil are a big hit, too, full of delicately balanced flavor. Our favorite entrée was the filet mignon. I often do not order a steak dish because chefs just consider it a must-have dish for the menu, but beyond the taste of great beef, the shallots and sauce were very satisfying. I find the autumn vegetable stew a bit bland, but beautifully presented.
At about this point in the meal my husband was commenting that this experience compared favorably to our recent experience at fine New York City restaurants. Although not on the outer edge of “edgy,” our meals and presentation were current with hot food trends, and we were happy to find this on the back roads of New Hampshire. Allen and Chef Fortin have a comfortable working relationship that allows Fortin to innovate, inspired by books and media, and Allen to encourage, with his recent exposure to hot dining scenes. After all, the food world is now just a giant global kitchen where food combinations and presentations are created and then copied at the speed of electrons. There is even some talk of chefs being able to trademark their recipes or presentations. Let’s hope not, as too many lawyers will spoil the proverbial bumbleberry broth.
In all, the scale of the inn is comfortable. Cozy common areas allow guests to converse and mingle with the innkeepers or just enjoy the crackle of the fireplaces. These human-sized moments would be rare in a larger hotel. More rare would be the attention to the individual plates Chef Fortin is afforded in the dining room.
Allen’s business philosophy is to exceed expectations. From the upscale evening dining to the luxury sheets and towels in the guest quarters to the fabulous three-course breakfast, he is right on mark. NH
Sugar Hill Inn
Route 117, Sugar Hill
Dinner for guests and the public Thursday-Monday, 6 p.m. to 9 p.m.
This article appears in the January 2007 issue of New Hampshire Magazine